A child who cannot hear a spoken sentence follows a signed conversation with ease. Another hears sounds but has had little reliable access to a shared language. What role does access to language play in how the brain develops?

01

Hearing and having access to a language are different experiences

A child may not hear speech but can have rich, continuous access to a natural sign language. Another may hear some sound without receiving a language they can reliably perceive and use. Heather Bortfeld's review starts from this distinction. When research groups children under the broad label of hearing loss, it risks confusing reduced auditory input with delayed or fragmented language experience. The two can coincide, but they are not the same cause or the same developmental story.

The language deprivation framework proposes that early access to a natural language is important for typical linguistic, cognitive and neural specialization. 'Access' is more precise than the name of a communication mode. Input must be perceivable in real time, sustained enough for learning and connected with responsive social interaction. A signed exchange can meet those conditions; spoken input that does not reach a child consistently may not.

This is why the opening comparison matters. The goal is not to rank sound against sign. It is to ask what experience the child actually receives. A study that records only whether a hearing device was fitted or which mode a family selected may miss the timing, continuity and quality of the language available to the child.

02

Specialization is built over time

Many adults show a stronger contribution from left-hemisphere networks to language tasks. It is tempting to picture that pattern as a fixed location present from birth. Bortfeld instead describes hemispheric specialization as a gradual tuning of distributed networks. Early responses can involve both hemispheres; connections become more efficient and asymmetric across development, influenced by experience. The relevant unit is not a single 'language spot' but the organization of communication among regions.

Network neuroscience studies patterns of connections, including how regions cluster locally and integrate with distant systems. Measures of efficiency, modularity and asymmetry can show how a developing network changes. They do not turn a scan into a simple score of how much language a child has. Different measurement methods capture different aspects, and age matters: a degree of lateralization that is ordinary at one stage may mean something different at another.

This network view also helps avoid a false opposition. A brain can preserve its broad organizational architecture while the timing or degree of language-related specialization changes. The review uses evidence from infants and children to hold both observations together. 'Atypical trajectory' is a description for research, not a judgment that a person has an inferior form of language.

03

Hearing loss offers a difficult natural comparison

Early sensorineural hearing loss lets researchers ask how experience shapes specialization when auditory input is reduced. Some studies find broadly preserved global network properties alongside altered or delayed emergence of leftward asymmetry, especially in systems involved in higher-order language processing. It would be easy to call the hearing loss itself the cause. Bortfeld cautions that many cohorts also had limited early access to a natural sign language, so the two experiences cannot be separated by those studies alone.

That is a classic problem of causal inference. If auditory input and language access differ together, a scan cannot tell which difference drove a developmental pattern. The review therefore asks for comparison groups that make the variables diverge: children with little auditory input but rich early signed language, and children whose access to any natural language was delayed. The groups must also be considered with care because family resources, intervention timing and other experiences vary.

Distinguishing hearing from access to language changes how a language delay is interpreted. If a delayed language outcome is attributed automatically to deafness, a preventable lack of accessible input may be overlooked. If every neural difference is described as a deficit, the study may ignore successful language learning through a different sensory route. The framework demands a more precise history before interpreting a brain measure.

04

Sign language is a full language route

Deaf children exposed from birth to a natural sign language provide a crucial comparison. They have little or no auditory input but can participate in a linguistically rich, socially embedded exchange. The review describes evidence that these children acquire structure at multiple levels—phonological, lexical and syntactic—along broadly typical developmental timelines. 'Phonological' here does not mean that language must be audible; signed languages also have patterned units and combinations.

This evidence tests the framework more directly than a comparison between hearing and deaf children whose linguistic histories are unknown. If a child develops language through a visual-manual route, the sensory channel cannot be equated with linguistic capacity. Studies of neural organization then ask whether early accessible sign supports aspects of language-related specialization even without ordinary auditory experience. The emerging answer is more nuanced than 'left brain for speech, right brain for signs'.

Bortfeld also discusses multimodal foundations of early language experience. Gaze, gesture, faces, interaction and timing contribute to learning in many children, not only those using sign. The broader point is that language develops within exchanges with people. Counting words or signs without considering whether the child can perceive and participate in those exchanges gives an incomplete picture.

05

Delay has different consequences from modality

The contrast appears most clearly when access to any natural language is delayed or absent. The review summarizes studies linking late language exposure with persistent difficulties across grammar and discourse, even when vocabulary and basic communication improve after later input. Complex syntax can be especially difficult. This pattern is not explained simply by the fact that the child did not hear. It concerns the timing and continuity of linguistic experience.

Neuroimaging studies associate delayed access with differences in specialization and connectivity, though the precise mechanisms remain under study. Research also links language deprivation to domains that use language as a tool, including aspects of executive function and understanding others' minds. These associations need careful interpretation: children do not share a single family, educational or medical history, and no individual scan can settle the whole causal account.

Still, the distinction carries a practical urgency. Waiting for one hoped-for modality while withholding an accessible one may cost time in a developmental period when language learning is underway. The review's message is not that a single intervention fits every child. It is that the availability of usable language is itself a variable worth protecting and measuring, rather than treating access through sign as a fallback after other options fail.

06

A network account improves the question

The framework brings three kinds of evidence together: what children can do with language, what sensory information reaches them and how neural connections change over time. A broad label such as 'typical' or 'atypical' cannot substitute for this history. A network may maintain global efficiency yet differ in a particular lateralization measure. A child may succeed in a signed language while differing from hearing peers on a sound-based task. Neither fact contradicts the other.

For research, Bortfeld calls for better longitudinal designs and more precise measures of actual language exposure. Children with early sign access are essential, but they must not be treated as an afterthought or a homogeneous group. Timing, quality and social responsiveness of input should be documented. Different imaging methods and analytic choices also require caution before comparing small cohorts.

The brain specializes through experience, and learning a language does not require that experience to arrive through sound. Interpreting a child's development requires asking when they gained access to a language they could reliably understand and use. That history helps families and professionals ask more precise questions; individualized support requires understanding the conditions of each child's life.

07

What the distinction changes

It changes the subject of explanation. Instead of asking why deafness 'caused' a broad developmental outcome, researchers can ask which aspects of auditory experience, language access and social interaction preceded it. Instead of assuming a fixed brain map, they can follow how networks specialize. Instead of comparing only groups with different hearing, they can compare children whose access to natural language diverged in a theoretically informative way.

The review does not deny that hearing loss can change sensory development or that medical technologies may matter. It asks that their effects not be conflated with the effects of inaccessible language. A child may use signed, spoken or more than one modality; the point is whether the input is genuinely available and supports continuing communication. The pathways can differ without ranking the children who travel them. Access can also change between home, school and clinic, so a broad label may hide the child's actual daily linguistic experience.

Bortfeld's synthesis remains a framework with causal questions still open. Its strength is to identify a comparison that older research often missed. Once sound and language are separated, the seeming paradox disappears: a child can hear little and learn much, while a child who hears something can still lack the language experience needed for development.

What to keep

  1. Auditory deprivation and language deprivation must be separated.
  2. Network specialization develops with experience rather than appearing fully formed.
  3. Early sign-language access is central to testing the framework.
?

The nuance

What this story does not let us claim

Hearing loss does not inevitably produce atypical language or brain organization; experiences and measures vary.

Go deeper: concepts and optional reading practice

Reversible cards

Test the concept

1 / 2

Topic assessment

Check whether you can explain the idea, not merely recognize it.

Every answer is grounded in the explanation above. Some questions introduce new cases to test whether you can apply and analyze the ideas, not merely recall them.

7 questions4 options per questionOne correct answer
01Which statement best captures the review’s central thesis?
02Which is the most appropriate operational definition of “Accessible language”?
03Which case correctly applies the central concept?
04If two studies obtain different results, which interpretation best preserves the logic of this guide?
05Which complementary conclusion belongs to the paper’s core argument?
06Which formulation best distinguishes “Hemispheric specialization” from a superficial label?
07Which limit should accompany any application of the paper to a new case?
Answer all seven questions.

Source & scope

Language Access and Hemispheric Specialization: A Network Neuroscience Framework for Typical and Atypical Language Development. Heather Bortfeld. Annual Review of Psychology, vol. 78 (2027). First published as a Review in Advance on September 29, 2026.

This editorial guide is an independent explanation. Consult the original publication for the studies, references and full context.

Open the original review ↗