You intend to finish an application tonight. Alone, it is easy to postpone. Beside a friend doing the same task, you begin; when someone checks every step, you tense up. Why might company help you make progress while monitoring makes it harder?
We also pursue goals alongside other people
When someone misses a goal, the familiar explanation looks inward: perhaps they lacked discipline, confidence or attention. Maya Enisman and her colleagues begin elsewhere. Behavior depends on the person and the environment, yet research on goal pursuit has often split those halves. One line studies individual self-regulation; another studies social influence. The review brings them together to ask how other people change the very processes through which an individual chooses and acts.
The authors arrange social factors along a continuum. At one end lie experiences nobody deliberately designs for the actor: exclusion, simple presence and population density. Farther along are models and group behavior, then expectations. At the active end are support and coercion. This is a map of how intentional the social influence is, not a ranking from weak to strong or from good to bad. A silent audience may matter greatly; an offered solution may fail.
The useful question is therefore not 'Do others influence us?' but 'Through what process, in which setting, and with what result?' Attention, a sense of being capable, concern about others' judgments and the ability to inhibit an impulse can all change. To show that a social factor caused a behavior through one of these processes, however, a study needs more than a correlation between company and outcome.
Exclusion can redirect attention—but not always usefully
Being left out has no single behavioral effect. A brief episode may sharpen attention to signs of reconnection. The review describes experimental work in which people excluded from a virtual ball game looked more toward smiling faces than angry ones. The pattern makes sense as a search for a route back to others. Yet exclusion also threatens belonging and can consume the resources needed for other goals. A person preoccupied with whether they are welcome may have less room to focus on the task in front of them.
Duration changes the story. A momentary rejection and chronic loneliness are not interchangeable exposures. The authors describe some potentially adaptive responses after acute exclusion but more consistently harmful patterns when isolation persists. It would therefore be misleading to say that rejection 'motivates people' as a general intervention principle. The same apparent increase in attention can coexist with emotional strain, and the target of the person's effort may shift from the original goal to restoring safety.
This distinction matters in schools, workplaces and health settings. If a student stops participating after being ignored, adding reminders to concentrate may miss the event that redirected concentration. A better investigation would examine whether the student seeks social cues, withdraws, avoids evaluation or regains access to supportive peers. The review supplies mechanisms to test, not a license to infer an inner state from one visible behavior.
An audience can help or hinder the same task
The mere presence of another person may alter performance even when that person gives no instruction. Some experiments find faster action when a peer is nearby; other tasks, especially unfamiliar or difficult ones, can suffer under observation. The review distinguishes competition, mere presence, an evaluating audience and working alongside someone else. Those situations often get grouped together as 'social pressure', but they present different demands to attention and self-presentation.
Population density adds another layer. Earlier studies of crowded residences linked density to greater social distance and less interaction, but experimental findings have not consistently supported a simple rule that more people means more withdrawal. The number of bodies per unit of space is only part of the experience. Control, norms and the meaning of that crowding can change what people do. A busy library can sustain focused work; a crowded room where one feels watched may do the opposite.
To distinguish how a study group influences behavior, researchers would need to examine whether it helps sustain a rhythm or whether public score comparisons shift attention toward reputation. These are possible explanations to test. Counting study hours is not enough: task difficulty, who is present, whether evaluation is expected and changes in attention or motivation also matter for interpreting what the group does.
Models and group behavior show what seems possible
A role model does more than demonstrate a technique. Seeing a relevant peer perform a difficult action can change expectations about whether the action is feasible for oneself. The review connects social examples with self-efficacy and with the perceived consequences of acting. Yet a model's effect depends on identification, similarity, distance and context. A spectacularly successful figure may inspire one person and make the same goal seem unattainable to another.
Group behavior offers another kind of information. If many people do something, an observer may infer that it is common, permitted or rewarding. Enisman and colleagues discuss work on pedestrian violations: people who witnessed others crossing improperly were more likely to perceive the behavior as common and to do it themselves, despite negative attitudes toward it. The example separates one's stated view from information gathered by watching the group.
A descriptive norm—what people actually do—is not identical to an injunctive norm—what people think one ought to do. A classroom may tell students to ask questions while everyone stays silent. A health campaign may praise one behavior while the visible peer group follows another. The review encourages us to examine both streams of information rather than assume that official approval decides conduct.
Expectations make the social demand explicit
Beyond watching what others do, people notice what important others want from them. A partner's hope, a team's rule or a public standard can make a behavior feel expected. Such expectations may support a valued goal, but they can also turn action into impression management: the person works to appear competent, loyal or acceptable rather than to perform the original task well. The review puts this normative pressure farther along its continuum because the social message becomes more directed.
That is why a social environment is not merely a source of motivation. It can alter which goal gets priority. A student may work to learn, then shift to avoiding embarrassment once test scores are publicly displayed. The outside observer sees effort in both cases, yet the underlying regulation differs. A program that rewards only visible compliance may mistake this shift for real engagement.
The authors connect group expectations with social norms, sanctions and perceptions of what others approve. But they do not claim that every expectation is imposed by a single powerful person. People also infer standards from a group, and those inferences can be wrong. Studying the pathway requires knowing whose judgment matters to the actor and whether the expected behavior supports, competes with or replaces the actor's own goal.
Help is not always experienced as help
At the active end of the continuum, another person may offer time, information, money or reassurance. Social support often sounds uniformly beneficial. The review describes a sharper distinction: believing that support would be available is consistently associated with positive outcomes, while actually receiving it has mixed effects. An offer can strengthen commitment and capacity; it can also feel intrusive, signal doubt about one's competence or arrive at the wrong moment.
The mechanism matters more than the label. Imagine two friends helping someone prepare an application. One asks what kind of help would be useful and proofreads a requested paragraph. The other rewrites the whole document without asking. Both actions can be called supportive; only the first may preserve the applicant's sense of control. The illustration does not assert a universal rule about proofreading. It shows why observed support and the recipient's interpretation must be studied together.
Coercion makes the social direction more forceful. Threats or constraints may produce immediate compliance while changing attention, motivation and relationships in ways that undermine later action. The review treats coercion as one social factor among others, not as a morally interchangeable form of help. Knowing that someone complied tells us little about whether the behavior is sustainable, chosen or accompanied by harm.
People also choose and change their environments
The review's diagram often points from social surroundings toward individual action. Its authors stress that the arrow also runs back. People seek or avoid company, join groups, leave relationships and shape the norms they later encounter. Someone who fears negative evaluation may avoid a resource that would have helped; repeated avoidance then makes the environment look less supportive. A theory that records only the external pressure misses this feedback.
Multiple influences can operate at once. A student may be lonely, sit in a crowded room, see a peer succeed, receive advice and worry about a parent's expectations on the same day. Much of the research reviewed isolates one factor, which is useful for understanding it but does not automatically show how the factors combine. The authors call for work that traces complete pathways from the social condition through self-regulatory processes to observed behavior, including interactions and bidirectional change.
Before adding another prompt, it helps to identify what is preventing the person from making progress. If a goal fails, ask who is present, what behavior the group models, whose judgment matters, whether help is wanted and whether the setting can be changed. Then measure what people actually do, not just what they promise. Personal effort still matters. Examining these relationships helps explain when other people support that effort and when they make it harder.
What to keep
- Social influence ranges from passive presence to direct intervention.
- Attention, self-efficacy and impression management are possible pathways.
- Interventions may need to change environments as well as individuals.
The nuance
What this story does not let us claim
The same social factor can help or hinder, and the full pathways from influence to behavior are not yet established in every context.
Go deeper: concepts and optional reading practice
Reversible cards
Test the concept
Topic assessment
Check whether you can explain the idea, not merely recognize it.
Every answer is grounded in the explanation above. Some questions introduce new cases to test whether you can apply and analyze the ideas, not merely recall them.
Source & scope
Social Regulation of Human Behavior. Maya Enisman, Minjae Seo, Molly G. Smith, Yubo Zhou, Benjamin R. Karney & Dolores Albarracín. Annual Review of Psychology, vol. 78 (2027). First published as a Review in Advance on September 30, 2026.
This editorial guide is an independent explanation. Consult the original publication for the studies, references and full context.
Open the original review ↗