Three neighbors disagree about a plan for their street. Each knows something the others do not and fears a different loss. How can they make a good decision when no one has all the information and they disagree on what a good outcome would be?

01

Knowing more does not settle every decision

A school must decide whether to close a building that is expensive to repair. The accounts show the cost, but cannot say how much a familiar place matters to families or what the closure would mean for children with longer journeys. More calculation may improve the figures without settling which losses are acceptable. The example captures the question Igor Grossmann and Nic M. Weststrate study: people must act even when the possible futures, values and standards for success are disputed.

The authors distinguish this kind of uncertainty from a puzzle with known options and probabilities. If the choices and scoring rule are fixed, calculating the best answer makes sense. In a family conflict or a public controversy, even the description of the problem may change as more people speak. A formula can assist, but cannot decide in advance whose concerns should count or whether the apparent options are the only ones available.

Their claim is therefore more precise than ‘wisdom beats intelligence.’ Intelligence helps with many parts of a decision. Wisdom is the effort to use knowledge, experience and other people's perspectives appropriately when the situation does not hand us a clear rule. The review treats it as a way of reasoning in context, not as a mysterious gift possessed by a few exceptional people.

02

Culture gives us tools, but the tools can clash

People rarely approach a hard choice empty-handed. They remember an older relative's advice, a story about someone who faced a similar crisis, or a saying such as ‘look before you leap.’ These inherited resources compress experience and suggest what to notice. Yet a second saying, ‘he who hesitates is lost,’ may recommend the opposite action. The review calls these shared models folk theories of wisdom. They are useful starting points, but they do not carry instructions for every circumstance.

Who is called wise also reflects a culture's expectations. People may admire practical leaders, reflective thinkers or caring figures for different reasons. In a study spanning twelve countries, judgments of wisdom involved both reflection and attention to others; warmth without discernment did not necessarily look wise. The pattern matters, but the authors also point out that earlier research concentrated heavily on North America and East Asia and left many communities underrepresented.

Cultural advice is passed on because it is memorable and because respected people use it, not only because it works everywhere. A practice that helped one generation in one setting may fit a new setting badly. Good judgment therefore cannot consist merely of collecting proverbs or imitating admired people. It must ask what the present problem shares with those earlier examples and where the comparison breaks down.

03

The useful pause before choosing

The review's central idea is that wisdom lies partly in managing the tools we already have. The authors call this perspectival metacognition: noticing what we do not know, considering how the problem looks from other positions and recognizing that circumstances may change. In ordinary language, it is the ability to step back from the first answer without freezing forever. A principal debating the school closure might realize that she knows the budget but has not heard from families who depend on the current location.

Grossmann and Weststrate describe three moves. First, seek missing input rather than assuming the available story is complete. Second, when two reasonable rules conflict, choose or combine them according to the situation: honesty and kindness, for example, need not be rivals in every conversation. Third, watch what happens after acting and revise the plan if its effects differ from what was expected. The sequence describes an ongoing adjustment, not a checklist that guarantees a good result.

This view also shifts wisdom beyond one person's head. A colleague who asks a hard question, a patient who corrects a doctor's assumption, or a meeting format that gives quiet participants time to speak can improve the reasoning itself. Wisdom may emerge from a relationship or a well-designed process. The person who appears decisive while ignoring these inputs may look impressive and still make a narrow decision.

04

Sound reasoning has a social test

The authors do not define a decision as wise simply because most people approve of its outcome. They ask how the decision was reached: whether the person acknowledged uncertainty, considered competing interests and adjusted to the particular circumstances. That choice avoids treating one culture's preferred ending as a universal score. It also makes a claim open to testing: do these habits of thought actually help people anticipate events, handle conflict or cooperate?

Studies discussed in the review relate wisdom-linked reasoning to emotional balance, openness to revising forecasts and some cooperative behavior. In public-goods experiments, prompts that encouraged people to consider interdependence helped sustain cooperation; simply allowing more time to think did not help everyone in the same way. Studies of political disagreement suggest that taking some distance from one's immediate position can reduce hostile interpretations and increase willingness to listen.

These findings are encouraging rather than a promise that a reflective person will always make a fair choice. Associations vary with the measure used and with the resources available to the person. Reflecting can be tiring; time pressure can limit it. An intervention may change a response in one experiment without transforming a community's institutions. The review treats the social benefits of wise reasoning as evidence to investigate, not as a moral property guaranteed by its definition.

05

Why a wisdom score can be misleading

Suppose a questionnaire asks, ‘I often recognize the limits of my knowledge.’ A person who rarely notices those limits may confidently agree. Someone more aware of them may answer cautiously. This is the humility paradox discussed in the review: self-ratings can partly capture an attractive self-image rather than how a person reasons when a real difficulty arises. A single score also hides the possibility that the same person reasons carefully at work and defensively at home.

Researchers therefore ask people to discuss specific dilemmas or describe recent conflicts. This lets them examine whether a person recognizes uncertainty and integrates viewpoints in an actual story. Yet a polished sentence can be a rehearsed social script; one response cannot reveal how often the person acts that way. The authors favor repeated observations across different situations, combining reports with behavior and other evidence, while acknowledging that such designs are costly.

Software can help score large numbers of narratives, but it introduces another trap. A language model may identify words that sound wise because those words resemble familiar cultural accounts of wisdom. It may miss the harder question: did the speaker really revise an assumption when challenged? The review calls for testing these tools across languages and settings, so a convenient measure does not quietly replace the psychological process it was meant to study.

06

Experience alone is not a teacher

‘Age brings wisdom’ and ‘adversity makes us stronger’ are comforting stories, but the studies reviewed give them little support as general rules. A synthesis found only a negligible average association between age and wisdom. Difficult experiences do not reliably increase wise reasoning either. Their effect depends partly on the kind of difficulty and on how a person works through it. Repeated conflict might teach someone to listen; it might equally train them to expect hostility.

The distinction between comparing people and following one person matters here. Finding that older adults score differently from younger adults would not prove that any one person became wiser as they aged. Longitudinal work is needed to see what changes within a life. The review also notes that social environments shape opportunities to seek advice, negotiate conflict and reflect on mistakes; calendar age leaves those conditions out.

Brief exercises can shift reasoning in the moment. One example is self-distancing: describing a personal conflict as if observing it from a little farther away. In a month-long field study, daily writing with such instructions modestly improved coded signs of wise reasoning compared with a more immersed writing condition. Whether the improvement lasts, transfers to difficult decisions and works similarly across cultures remains open. A temporary boost is not the same as a durable habit.

07

Making space for wiser decisions

The school in our opening example cannot hire a ‘wise person’ and assume the problem is solved. It can instead create a process: publish the constraints, hear families with different needs, invite objections to the favored plan, decide with reasons that others can inspect and revisit effects after the change. None of these steps guarantees agreement. Together they make it less likely that one confident viewpoint will settle a decision affecting many people.

This institutional implication follows from the review's ecological account. Relationships, meeting rules and accountability systems can make perspective-taking easier or harder. The authors discuss settings from clinical conversations to citizens' assemblies as possible scaffolds for judgment. They also consider artificial intelligence: a system may retrieve vast quantities of information while failing to recognize uncertainty or conflicting values. Fluency and knowledge alone are poor substitutes for checking limits and listening to affected people.

The practical invitation is neither endless doubt nor faith in a special type of person. When a problem has no clean answer, ask which voices and facts are missing, which familiar rule may not fit, and what would show that the decision needs revision. That approach does not remove uncertainty. It helps people remain responsible for what they do while uncertainty is still there.

What to keep

  1. Recognize the limits of one's knowledge.
  2. Coordinate perspectives rather than treating one viewpoint as complete.
  3. Evaluate wisdom in context, not only as a fixed personal score.
?

The nuance

What this story does not let us claim

Wise reasoning is situated: a person may reason well in one context and poorly in another, and cultural traditions differ.

Go deeper: concepts and optional reading practice

Reversible cards

Test the concept

1 / 2

Topic assessment

Check whether you can explain the idea, not merely recognize it.

Every answer is grounded in the explanation above. Some questions introduce new cases to test whether you can apply and analyze the ideas, not merely recall them.

7 questions4 options per questionOne correct answer
01Which statement best captures the review’s central thesis?
02Which is the most appropriate operational definition of “Metacognition”?
03Which case correctly applies the central concept?
04If two studies obtain different results, which interpretation best preserves the logic of this guide?
05Which complementary conclusion belongs to the paper’s core argument?
06Which formulation best distinguishes “Perspective taking” from a superficial label?
07Which limit should accompany any application of the paper to a new case?
Answer all seven questions.

Source & scope

Navigating the Unknown: The Sociocultural and Metacognitive Architecture of Wisdom. Igor Grossmann & Nic M. Weststrate. Annual Review of Psychology, vol. 78 (2027). First published as a Review in Advance on August 17, 2026.

This editorial guide is an independent explanation. Consult the original publication for the studies, references and full context.

Open the original review ↗