A man refuses help in front of his teammates and accepts the same help later in private. The need remains the same. What changes when other people are watching, and what does he expect them to think of his decision?
A decision in front of different audiences
A father wants to take time away from work to care for his child. At home, his partner welcomes the decision. At work, he expects coworkers to admire the man who stays late and to question the man who leaves early. The hours he can actually take depend on policy and money, but his sense of what a ‘good man’ does also depends on whose judgment he anticipates. Colette Van Laar and colleagues examine this social side of men's identities.
The review does not propose one fixed kind of man. Masculinities differ across people and settings, and norms are changing. Some expectations prize toughness, self-reliance and dominance; others value care and emotional openness. The authors ask how identifying with a group can make its norms attractive, how a threat to one's standing can make them feel compulsory and how different audiences reward or punish different performances.
The word audience is more than a metaphor for people in a room. It can be a partner, a male friend, a manager, an online group or an imagined group whose opinion matters. A man may behave differently when the audience changes or when he learns that peers are more accepting than he assumed. Understanding the audience helps explain why a private belief does not always become a public action.
A status some feel required to prove
Some studies reviewed describe manhood as a status that must be earned and maintained through visible behavior. In experiments, men given false feedback suggesting that they fell short of a masculine ideal sometimes responded with more stereotypically masculine choices than men in control conditions. The point is not that every man is always proving himself. It is that a threatened identity can change behavior when the person values that identity and expects a judgment.
Norms have positive and negative sides: a person may be encouraged to be independent, and also warned not to look vulnerable. The second kind can be especially restrictive. Avoiding a doctor's visit, concealing worry or laughing along at a cruel joke can become ways to avoid being judged by others. The research does not excuse harm by naming its social source. It explains why appeals to ‘just choose differently’ may fail when the cost of differing is imposed by a group.
The authors connect this account with social identity theory. People often want their important groups to be valued and distinct. What counts as a valued member can then shape choices, especially when the group's standing feels under threat. Yet the same attachment can support change: if respected group members visibly redefine courage to include care or speaking against harassment, a group norm can move rather than merely constrain.
The cost can appear in health and friendship
When self-reliance is treated as proof of masculinity, asking for help may feel like failure. The review brings together studies linking stronger adherence to traditional masculine norms with less health-promoting behavior, less psychological help-seeking and, in some settings, greater risk-taking. These are population patterns and associations; they do not explain one person's illness, nor do they mean all forms of masculinity damage health.
The social cost can be quieter than a risky choice. Studies in the review suggest men may share positive news with friends while holding back worries or painful experiences more than they would prefer. Fear of being seen as weak or insufficiently masculine can narrow emotional conversations among male peers. A romantic partner may then become a main source of intimacy and help maintaining a wider network. If that relationship ends, the shortage of other close ties becomes especially visible.
This account should not turn women partners into the natural managers of men's emotional lives. It asks how friendships and social norms distribute support. An intervention that simply tells men to disclose more could fail if the audience still punishes vulnerability. A better question is what would make friendship, care and help-seeking feel safe and valued, and which groups already demonstrate different possibilities.
Work and care are shaped together
A father cannot choose a caregiving role through attitude alone if his workplace makes leave costly or his coworkers treat long hours as proof of worth. The review discusses a persistent breadwinner ideal and an image of the ideal worker with few responsibilities at home. It also describes supervisors who support flexibility and model boundaries between work and family. These audiences can make caregiving either more possible or more socially expensive.
The authors describe workplace cultures that reward competition, extreme hours and a work-first identity. They can pressure everyone, but may particularly confront men who want to depart from a masculine ideal attached to work. In contrast, learning that male peers actually support a more caring role can change self-description and intentions. Perceived norms matter, and those perceptions can be mistaken. Making support visible can alter what people believe the audience expects.
This does not reduce an unequal division of unpaid work to men's feelings. Pay, leave rules, hiring and promotion all shape the available choices. A supportive speech by a manager is weaker than a schedule and evaluation system that lets people use leave without penalty. The social identity account adds a layer: even a formal option may go unused if taking it threatens a valued standing among peers.
Social change can feel like threat or possibility
Changes toward gender equality do not produce one response among men. Some may welcome a broader range of roles; others may see a loss of status or interpret gains for women as losses for themselves. The review examines how attachment to traditional roles, beliefs about group privilege and perceived threats influence support or opposition. These reactions are situated: they depend on political messages, institutions and the audiences that make a view feel normal or disloyal.
A threatened identity can lead to defensiveness or, in some situations, overt hostility. The authors discuss links between certain norms and aggression, including aggression aimed at women and gender-diverse people. Naming those links is important without treating violence as an inevitable expression of being a man. Individuals remain responsible for their actions; the research asks which norms and conditions make harmful actions more likely and which can interrupt them.
Men can also act as allies. Their position may give them influence with other men or within organizations; they can challenge a harmful joke, support a fair policy or share responsibility for care. The motive and effect still matter. Allyship is more than a favorable self-image or a public declaration. A useful evaluation asks whether people affected by inequality gain safety, voice and practical change.
The audience is often imagined incorrectly
The review's distinctive idea is that behavior depends not only on what a man believes about himself, but also on whom he thinks is watching. In one line of studies, men expected other men to disapprove when someone challenged a sexist act. Their willingness to intervene fell in public even when their own private view was more supportive. If the expected disapproval is mistaken, silence can reproduce a norm that few peers actually endorse.
The influence of the audience is not uniform. Men who strongly identify with their group or see manhood as easily lost may respond differently from those who do not. A supervisor's approval may weigh more than a stranger's, and a trusted friend's judgment may weigh differently from that of an online crowd. The authors argue that an interaction between self-concept and audience is more informative than saying simply that ‘men behave this way.’
This points toward testable interventions. If peers truly support caregiving or challenging harassment, making that support visible might reduce mistaken pressure. But a message about peer approval will not replace workplace protections or prevent sanctions if the audience really is hostile. Researchers must measure the audience rather than assume its attitudes, and examine whose approval matters in each setting.
Changing the stage can change the act
Return to the father considering time for care. His choice will be shaped by leave policy, household resources and the reactions he expects. A useful response changes both the formal opportunity and the social meaning of using it. Supervisors can model caregiving, peers can stop treating it as failure and families can negotiate the work rather than assigning it by default. None guarantees a particular choice; all change what choices feel possible.
The review's implications extend to health, friendships and equality initiatives. Make help-seeking accessible without attaching shame. Build spaces where emotional openness is possible among friends, not only with a romantic partner. Judge allyship by changes in practice and institutions. In each case, asking ‘Who is watching, and what do they reward?’ can reveal a barrier that a message aimed only at the individual misses.
There are also limits. Much of the evidence comes from particular Western settings and experimental tasks; different cultures, ages and identities may organize masculinity differently. The point is not to replace one stereotype with another. It is to see men's behavior as shaped by relationships and changing norms, and then test which conditions permit healthier, fairer ways to live with others.
What to keep
- Masculinity is socially situated.
- Audiences regulate identity performance.
- Threat and allyship can coexist with change.
The nuance
What this story does not let us claim
Men and masculinities are heterogeneous; context, class, race, sexuality and culture shape the pattern.
Go deeper: concepts and optional reading practice
Reversible cards
Test the concept
Topic assessment
Check whether you can explain the idea, not merely recognize it.
Every answer is grounded in the explanation above. Some questions introduce new cases to test whether you can apply and analyze the ideas, not merely recall them.
Source & scope
Men's Self and Identity and Their Relations to Others in a Changing World. Colette Van Laar, Tony Holman, Sarah Grootjans & Aster Van Rossum. Annual Review of Psychology, vol. 77 (2026).
This editorial guide is an independent explanation. Consult the original publication for the studies, references and full context.
Open the original review ↗