A school announces that everyone belongs. Yet its newest teachers eat separately and miss the conversations where decisions are made. What would need to change for inclusion to become part of everyday life?
When rules change and everyday practices stay the same
An organization can sincerely want equal opportunity and still reproduce old patterns. New people arrive, training sessions are held and a public statement is issued. Then the same people exchange advice in the same private conversations, the same careers are praised, and the same unwritten rules decide who gets heard. Nilanjana Dasgupta begins from this gap between a declared wish and an everyday culture. Her question is how a change in individual behavior becomes a change in the relationships that make a local institution work.
Much culture-change work starts with the person: teach the correct facts, alter beliefs, then expect fairer conduct. The review challenges the idea that this sequence is sufficient or always necessary. Situations can steer who interacts and what they do even before people report a changed attitude. Conversely, a changed belief may have little effect if the environment still restricts access to information or rewards conformity to an old norm.
Understanding how beliefs change requires tracing the path from the setting to relationships: from an arrangement in a hallway or a rule in a meeting, to repeated encounters, to relationships and finally to the local culture. Calling a training program successful because participants liked it would skip most of that path.
Space quietly distributes opportunity
The first situational force is physical design. No room is neutral: portraits, names on buildings and celebrated objects suggest who is admired there. Floor plans place some people within easy reach and others far apart. The distance may look trivial until it determines who has a casual conversation after a meeting, hears about a project early or is introduced to someone with influence. These small encounters can build an information network that is unavailable to a colleague across the building.
Dasgupta connects physical proximity with relationship formation and access to social capital. People near one another tend to encounter each other more, and such encounters can alter tastes, preferences and opportunities. The review also considers how visible markers of prestige invite an inference: if those honored share one social identity, observers may begin to associate that identity with the qualities needed for success. The choice of who receives visible recognition can therefore influence expectations about who will succeed.
A practical response would be to examine actual routes of contact and influence. Who sits near decision makers? Who is invited into informal exchanges? Whose achievements are visible on walls and screens? Moving desks or changing portraits is no automatic cure. But without noticing these arrangements, an institution may keep asking excluded people to network harder inside a geography that gives them fewer chances to do so.
The rulebook is smaller than the rules
The second force consists of norms, conventions and the knowledge of which rules can be bent. A newcomer may read every formal document and still miss the important map: who can ask for an exception, what kind of disagreement is welcome, when a project is quietly assigned and which manner of speaking sounds credible. Someone raised inside the institution's dominant social world may acquire that map almost without noticing. Another person must spend attention deciphering it while also doing the job.
The review calls the friction between a person's familiar practices and institutional norms a cultural mismatch. It is not simply a problem of personal confidence. If upper-middle-class norms structure an academic or professional setting, someone unfamiliar with them can miss chances, face avoidable misunderstandings and feel that they do not belong. The same formal rule can therefore be experienced differently by people who possess different informal knowledge.
One tempting response is to coach every newcomer to fit existing practices. Some orientation may help, but that leaves the burden and the definition of 'normal' untouched. A deeper question is which unwritten rules are necessary, which merely protect insiders, and how access to exceptions and information is distributed. Culture change becomes more credible when the institution examines its own habits as well as the newcomer.
Stories tell people what the world permits
The third force is narrative. A story about a brilliant founder, a deserving winner or a supposedly natural hierarchy does more than entertain. It gives listeners a way to explain why people occupy different positions. Dasgupta reviews work on how stories draw audiences into a character's perspective and make events feel personally meaningful. They can make an unfamiliar experience easier to imagine; they can also make an unequal arrangement seem inevitable if that is the only plot people hear.
A familiar merit story might say that every successful employee simply worked harder. It can contain true episodes of effort while hiding the contacts, permissions and favorable conditions that made those efforts visible. An alternative story can reveal barriers and cooperation without claiming that effort never matters. The issue is not to replace facts with sentiment, but to notice that facts arrive inside explanations of who deserves status and why.
The review distinguishes narratives from a strategy that relies only on statistics or direct correction of false beliefs. Stories can invite perspective taking and emotional identification, but their effects depend on content, audience and context. A responsible institution would ask which stories are repeated at ceremonies, in mentoring and on its website, whose voices are absent, and whether a new story changes relationships rather than merely making a campaign more memorable.
Who is seen at the top changes the horizon
The fourth force is the visibility of people with high status and the groups to which they belong. People learn what success looks like by noticing who receives recognition. When every celebrated leader appears to come from one group, that pattern may make its members seem especially suited to lead and others seem like exceptions. When the pattern changes, a different future can become imaginable. Representation is therefore not cosmetic, but neither is it enough to count faces.
Dasgupta places high-status exemplars alongside physical design, norms and stories because their meaning depends on the environment around them. A visibly diverse leadership team may inspire, yet it can also be used to imply that unequal access has already vanished. A person elevated as an exceptional token may face pressure to distance themselves from their group. What matters is whether visibility comes with influence, genuine relationships and routes for others to advance.
The review is careful about the move from an individual example to a general belief. Observers may generalize admired qualities from one person to a category, but which categories are noticed and how the person is portrayed matter. Alongside who appears in a photograph, we need to examine who can change a decision, mentor a newcomer and participate routinely in leadership.
Relationships are the missing middle
The four forces work at different points, but their common route runs through interaction. Space permits or prevents encounters. Rules make some encounters easy and others risky. Stories shape how participants interpret one another. Exemplars signal whose ideas carry authority. Repeated over time, these moments can become the local pattern people call culture. That is more concrete than imagining culture as a mood that changes after a speech.
It also exposes a weakness in simple measures of progress. A survey can show that employees endorse equality while mentoring, collaboration and decision-making networks remain unchanged. A headcount can rise while access to consequential assignments stays concentrated. Dasgupta wants research to connect individual belief and action to interpersonal relationships and higher-order change, instead of assuming that improvement at one level must automatically flow into the next.
This does not yield a universal recipe. A classroom, laboratory and corporation have different histories and power structures. The review points to places where evidence remains thin and asks for stronger tests of the routes from situational features to durable change. A responsible evaluation would measure not just what people say after an intervention, but who gains information, who forms useful ties, whose proposals are heard and whether the change lasts.
A more demanding definition of change
The review returns the 'power of situations' to a debate that often treats inclusion as a test of individual virtue. A person can make better choices; those choices matter. But people act inside arrangements that distribute contact, information, credibility and status. If those arrangements stay intact, the organization can ask every newcomer to adapt while calling the result equal opportunity.
Evaluating cultural change requires observing how opportunities are distributed in everyday life. Map the ordinary moments where opportunity travels: the seat after a meeting, the invitation to join a conversation, the story told about a promotion, the person allowed to bend a rule. Then ask which of those moments can be redesigned and how the result would be observed. Evaluation needs to follow that path: a visible change in a rule may take time to alter the encounters and relationships it makes possible.
Dasgupta does not claim that situations control everyone or that four changes will abolish inequality. Her framework identifies levers that are easy to overlook precisely because they feel like background. A culture becomes more inclusive only if altered situations repeatedly support different interactions and relationships. The difficult part is checking whether that process actually happened.
What to keep
- Situations shape interaction as well as beliefs.
- Informal access and power matter alongside representation.
- Culture change requires observing relationships and outcomes over time.
The nuance
What this story does not let us claim
The four forces are a framework for inquiry, not a guarantee that any single design change will create equality.
Go deeper: concepts and optional reading practice
Reversible cards
Test the concept
Topic assessment
Check whether you can explain the idea, not merely recognize it.
Every answer is grounded in the explanation above. Some questions introduce new cases to test whether you can apply and analyze the ideas, not merely recall them.
Source & scope
Psychology of Culture Change: The Power of Situations Returns. Nilanjana Dasgupta. Annual Review of Psychology, vol. 78 (2027). First published as a Review in Advance on September 30, 2026.
This editorial guide is an independent explanation. Consult the original publication for the studies, references and full context.
Open the original review ↗